Monday, May 23, 2011

RE: SebastiAn - Embody



I'm not exactly a fan of Odd Future but the debate over their popularity amongst middle-class white kids (and relative exclusion by the black hip-hop community) due seemingly to the fetishization of black rage (read here or see here) and the controversy surrounding their misogynist lyrics encapsulated by a public tirade by Tegan & Sara of all people has definitely got me interested.

I believe this to be a more complex debate than previous hip-hop critiques precisely because the audience is predominantly white. A younger Arthur (i.e. pre-thirties, i.e. like last week) would have been all for Tyler, the creator spouting off how radical and disruptive this is to middle-America but it's middle-America who's eating this shit up thus, effacing its critical force. A younger Arthur would have been like, he's not actually promoting hatred against women, he's just being hypothetical but after reading Tyler's tweet responding to T&S, one can't continue to separate theory/praxis. A younger Arthur, now exhausting all excuses, would have been like, its fucking art, art is shocking sometimes. But rape fantasies aren't shocking to me anymore, and thus, following the logic, can't hold up as art.

So the question is, am I getting old or what?!? Please shed some light on this. Am I missing something about Odd Futures that will bring me back to my allegiance with the 'dark side' of hip-hop or have my critical politics finally trumped my musical tastes?

3 comments:

  1. I think you'd find this article interesting:
    http://www.guardian.co.uk/music/musicblog/2011/may/09/hip-hop-homophobia?INTCMP=SRCH

    But yeah, I don't see the hype surrounding Tyler - this 'shock & awe' lyrical shit has been tried a few times before, it's just getting old now. For me, hip-hop as an art form has been more about production than wordplay - that's my own bias I suppose, but part of it is that I've never been able to justify the misogyny, the homophobia, the glorification of violence as 'story-telling'. None of the latter constitutes an effective mode of subversion or resistance imo.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Awesome article and so well put Sune.

    And the concomitant conclusion is I AM getting older! but wiser nonetheless ;)

    Will any of you be at tomorrow's Future of Global Governance 'event'w/ headliners Gill and Sassen? I'm headin' so hopefully I'll see some of you there.

    Peace!

    ReplyDelete
  3. either you're getting old or hip-hop is aging.
    or maybe both.

    :)

    ReplyDelete